Spend enough time posting about Christianity on social media and you'll eventually meet somebody who knows exactly what God thinks about everything.

Everything.

They know what God thinks about gay people, women preaching, immigration, abortion, politics, and probably whether it's a sin to put pineapple on pizza. (It probably is).

And they've got Bible verses to prove it.

I get these folks in my comments pretty regularly. Usually, somewhere around the third exchange, they'll announce that they don't care what theologians or biblical scholars say because they "just believe what the Bible says."

Well, hell. Why didn't I think of that?

All those years studying theology, and apparently I could've saved myself a lot of time and money by just believing what the Bible says.

Except there's a problem.

When somebody tells me they just believe what the Bible says, what I generally hear is that they believe what somebody taught them the Bible says. Which is fine, as far as it goes. We all learn from somebody. I've spent years studying this stuff, and I still run across things that make me rethink something I was pretty sure about. But some folks have managed to skip that last part entirely. 

They've got their answers. 
God agrees with them. 
Case closed.

It reminds me of those old Magic Eight Balls.

Remember those? You'd ask whether your crush liked you, shake the thing, and wait for a little blue triangle to reveal your romantic future.

"OUTLOOK GOOD."
"ASK AGAIN LATER."
"MY SOURCES SAY NO."

You know, for a toy that knew absolutely nothing, it was remarkably confident. And I think some Christians have developed a biblical version.

Only theirs doesn't say "REPLY HAZY, TRY AGAIN."

It says "THUS SAITH THE LORD.”

Introducing the Biblical Inerrancy Edition!

That's right, folks. For the low, low price of never having to reconsider anything you've been taught, you too can own the Biblical Inerrancy Magic Eight Ball.

Just ask your question, shake vigorously, and receive the answer you were hoping for.

Question: Can women preach?
Answer: THE BIBLE CLEARLY SAYS NO.

Question: Should Christians sell their possessions and give to the poor?
Answer: HISTORICAL CONTEXT REQUIRED.

Question: What about loving your enemies?
Answer: SURELY JESUS DIDN'T MEAN EVERYBODY.

Question: Should we welcome immigrants?
Answer: PLEASE CONSULT YOUR PREFERRED POLITICAL PARTY.

Question: What about that camel-through-the-eye-of-a-needle business?
Answer: ASK AGAIN AFTER THE STEWARDSHIP CAMPAIGN.

It's a remarkable little product.

It even comes with a lifetime warranty against changing your mind.

But the Bible Is Inerrant!

I can practically hear somebody warming up their keyboard. "But the Bible is the inerrant Word of God!"

Okay. Let's talk about that.

For starters, the Bible doesn't contain a declaration that the entire collection of books we now call the Bible is inerrant. That's a claim Christians developed about scripture, and Christians have disagreed about biblical authority for a very long time.

Hell, we don't even all have the same number of books in our Bibles.

But let's say you believe the Bible is completely without error. Fine. We can work with that for a minute. Here's what I don't understand.

Why would believing the Bible cannot be wrong mean that you cannot be wrong about what it means?

Take women preaching. One Christian says the Bible clearly prohibits it. Another says the Bible supports women preaching and leading congregations. Both can point to scripture. Both may believe every word of it is true. And both cannot be right about whether women should be allowed to preach.

Now what?

Well, somebody's going to have to do some interpreting.

We're going to have to look at what the passages actually say, who wrote them, who they were written to, what was happening at the time, and how they fit with other biblical writings.

You know, all that stuff biblical scholars do. The stuff we're apparently supposed to ignore because Brother Steve already knows what God meant.

There's something wonderfully convenient about declaring the Bible incapable of error and then treating your own interpretation as though it enjoys the same protection.

I'm not sure how that works, but it's a hell of a deal if you can get it. 

Where do I sign up?!

The Eight Ball Has More Than One Answer

Now we get to something that really makes people nervous: The Bible doesn't always agree with itself.

There. I said it.

And before somebody starts reaching for the smelling salts, this shouldn't be particularly shocking. The Bible wasn't written by one person sitting at a desk while God dictated the answers. It's a collection of writings from different people, living in different places, across many centuries. They had different experiences, different concerns, and sometimes different understandings of God.

And yes, sometimes they disagreed.

Let's give the Eight Ball another shake.

Question: Does God punish children for their parents' sins?
Exodus 20:5: God visits the wrongdoing of parents upon subsequent generations.
Ezekiel 18:20: Children aren't held responsible for their parents' sins.

Well, shit.

Let's try another.

Question: Does God change God's mind?
Numbers 23:19: God isn't a human being who changes their mind.
Exodus 32:14: God changes course after Moses intercedes.

Apparently, the Eight Ball has some unresolved theological issues. And there's plenty more where those came from.

Job challenges the tidy explanations for suffering found elsewhere in biblical wisdom literature. The Gospel writers don't always tell the same stories the same way. Different biblical authors have different things to say about law, judgment, mercy, and what faithfulness looks like.

Now, I know what's coming.

Somebody's already preparing a seventeen-paragraph explanation for why those passages don't actually disagree. I've read plenty of those explanations. Some are thoughtful and worth considering. Others require the kind of contortions that ought to qualify somebody for an Olympic gymnastics team.

And to be fair, not every difference is a contradiction. Sometimes the writers are addressing different questions or emphasizing different things. But here's what I find interesting. The minute you start explaining how two passages fit together, you're interpreting the Bible.

You're deciding how context matters. 
You're deciding what words mean. 
You're deciding which passages help explain the others.

Which is exactly what you were telling me I shouldn't do when I questioned your interpretation.

Funny how that works.

Personally, I don't need every biblical writer to agree with every other biblical writer. I rather like that they don’t. There's something fascinating about reading people wrestle with God, justice, suffering, and what it means to live faithfully, particularly when later writers challenge ideas they inherited from earlier ones.

I don't think we honor those voices by pretending they all said the same thing. And I certainly don't think the Bible becomes more valuable when we spend our time trying to make its disagreements disappear.

The Bible doesn't always agree with itself. Maybe that's an invitation to think rather than an obligation to explain the disagreements away.

Funny How Context Works

There's another fascinating feature of the Biblical Inerrancy Magic Eight Ball. It seems to know exactly when context matters.

Jesus says to love your enemies?
Well, we need to understand what he meant by enemies.

Jesus tells a wealthy man to sell everything and give to the poor?
Clearly, that was a special circumstance.

Jesus warns about the dangers of wealth?
Let's not get carried away. We've got a building campaign coming up.

But find a passage that can be used to keep women out of leadership or LGBTQ+ people out of the church? Suddenly, everybody's a biblical literalist.

No context necessary. 
No discussion permitted.
God said it. 
That settles it.

Apparently, some verses come with an interpretation and others come with a padlock. And before my progressive Christian friends start nodding a little too enthusiastically, we do some of this ourselves. We've got passages we love, passages we'd rather not talk about, and interpretations we've grown pretty comfortable defending.

I know I do.

The question isn't whether we're interpreting the Bible. Everybody does that. The question is whether we're willing to admit it, examine our assumptions, and occasionally reconsider something we've believed for years. Because when we refuse to do that, something rather troubling happens.

We take our understanding of an ancient text and present it as God's unquestionable opinion. And when somebody challenges us, we accuse them of challenging God.

Think about that for a minute.

You read a passage. You decide what it means. Then you announce that anybody who disagrees with you is disagreeing with the Almighty. That's an extraordinary amount of authority to give yourself.

Especially when you're using it to tell other people how they're allowed to live.

Put Down the Damn Eight Ball, Karen

Look, I don't have a problem with people taking the Bible seriously. Quite the opposite. I wish more Christians would. But taking it seriously ought to involve actually paying attention to what we're reading.

Who wrote it? 
Why? 
What was happening? 
What kind of writing is it? 
What did those words mean to the people who first heard them?

And what do we do when another biblical writer sees things differently?

Those aren't attacks on scripture. They're the kinds of questions people ask when they care enough about something to understand it. And sometimes the answers are uncomfortable.

Sometimes they challenge something we've believed since childhood. Sometimes they expose prejudices we've managed to dress up in religious language. Sometimes they leave us with more questions than we started with.

I can live with that.

What I have a harder time with is somebody showing up in my comments, dropping a Bible verse, and acting like they've just delivered the final ruling from the Supreme Court of Heaven. Particularly when they haven't given much thought to what the passage actually means.

I don't expect everybody to have a theology degree. I don't expect everybody to agree with me, either. That would be a pretty boring conversation, and I'd probably start wondering what was wrong with everybody.

But a little humility wouldn't hurt.

If your reading of the Bible always confirms what you already believe, never makes you uncomfortable, and somehow results in God agreeing with you on every controversial issue, you might want to check what you're doing.

Because there's a difference between reading scripture and using scripture to reassure yourself that you're right.

And if you keep shaking until you get the answer you wanted, I'm not convinced you're listening to God.

I think you're playing with a damn Eight Ball.

SIGNS POINT TO YES.

Of course they do.

“UPGRADE” available only on web page.