Imagine there is a heaven. Then, imagine getting to heaven and discovering the whole thing comes down to an interview. You’re asked what you believe about Jesus. You say you’ve spent a good bit of your life trying to do what he taught. The person behind the desk looks down at the form.

“Right. But that’s not what I asked.”

The version of heaven I grew up with didn’t have a desk, as far as I knew. It was probably more like a lectern at the pearly gates. It did have a right answer, though. And once you were sure you had it, you could spend a surprising amount of time worrying about whether people who’d never heard the question were going to hell.

That’s God the Border Guard, the next portrait in “The Gods We Inherited”. This God sorts people by whether they belong. And if we’re comfortable imagining God doing that for eternity, I wonder what it does to our judgment when somebody proposes doing it here.

The People on the Other Side of the Desk

A church can help people find a place to belong. So can a country. I understand wanting to protect a community you love. I’m a pastor. If somebody threatens people in my congregation, I’m going to do something about it. I’m also going to need a better reason than “they’re not one of us.”

A border can tell you where a government’s authority ends. It can’t tell you whose fear matters. But listen to how easily “they don’t belong here” becomes an answer to a question nobody asked about belonging. Should a sick person get care? Should someone fleeing danger get a fair hearing? We can get so busy arguing over who gets to be here that we stop asking what we’re doing to people who already are.

This is where I get especially uneasy when Christians talk about protecting a Christian nation. If you want to make the case for an immigration policy, make it. Tell us who it helps, who it hurts, and why you think that’s justified. Calling it Christian doesn’t get you out of answering any of that. Seems to me it ought to make the questions harder.

Leviticus 19 tells the Israelites to treat the foreigner living among them like someone born among them, and to love that person as themselves. The reason given is that they know what it is to live as foreigners in Egypt. That’s a particular instruction to an ancient people, and it won’t write a modern immigration bill for us. But it does ask something of people who already have a place to live: remember what it’s like to be the one who needs a place.

Wait. You Were Where?

Matthew 25 ought to be perfect for God the Border Guard. It has a throne, a separation, and a terrible fate for the people on the wrong side. I don’t believe in eternal punishment, and I’m not going to pretend the story doesn’t go there. But look at what Jesus does with the judgment scene. The king says, “I was a stranger and you welcomed me.” The people who did the welcoming don’t even know when they did it.

It’s an odd admissions interview. Nobody gets asked what they believe about the king. They’re asked, in effect, what they did when somebody needed food or a place to be received. And the king identifies with the person they could have turned away.

I like that reading right up until it asks something of me. My church can say everybody’s welcome, and I can mean it. If someone can’t get up the steps, though, how much does it matter that I meant it? There’s a point at which the church needs to quit congratulating itself on the sign and figure out the damn steps.

I think that’s what I missed when I was busy worrying about heaven’s guest list. 

I thought the big question was whether Jesus would let somebody in. 

In the story Jesus tells, he’s the one waiting to see if we will.

“UPGRADE” only appears on the web page.